Ethical leadership article critique peer review

Ethical Leadership Article Critique Peer Review Assignment Instructions


The Ethical Leadership Article Critique Peer Review assignment is an opportunity for you to learn from the analysis of a fellow student while seeking to deepen the article and subject matter evaluation. As you practice evaluating other’s scholarly efforts, you will deepen your understanding of ethical leadership theory while practicing grace-based confrontation of your fellow student within the ethical framework. This is a skill vital in practicing Christian ethical leadership.


You will be provided a randomly chosen peer’s Ethical Leadership Article Critique by Tuesday of the assignment week which you will evaluate, develop additional literature supporting or contesting the original article or critique, and write your peer review (critique) of the critique. Your paper should address whether you agree with the fellow student’s critique, provide your assessment of the quality of the critique, and present what additional critiques or expanded thoughts you may have. You should draw on in-course and extra-course materials to support your position and reference no less than 1 additional (not used in the original critique) source in addition to the course textbooks. All referenced material must be properly cited and listed on the references page. The peer review submission is to be an APA paper with the body of the paper 3-4 pages excluding the title page, abstract, and references pages.

Examination of ethical leadership

The BMAL 770 Research Paper assignment is an examination of ethical leadership
encompassing the range of complex issues, constructs, forces, and worldviews that influence the
contemporary leader. The purpose is for you to develop and present your unique concept of the
ethical leader by assessing, describing, supporting, and presenting those elements considered
most critical within the limits of a 10-14 page scholarly paper. This assignment incorporates self-
evaluation and thoughts about how these concepts may be applied as you analyze theories and
construct solutions using sound ethical, reasoning, and Christian worldview frameworks.


The Research Paper must be in APA format with 10-14 pages in the body plus a cover page,
abstract, and references page. Keeping the paper within the range is part of the challenge of
scholarly writing. No less than 6 sources in addition to any course textbooks should be
referenced. Merida textbook, must be included and integrated into the
discussion as one of the textbooks. All referenced material must be properly cited and listed on
the references page.
Be sure to follow all APA standards including double-space, Times New Roman 12-point or
other APA approved font, 1-inch margins, no contractions or unnecessary (non-heading) bolding.
Use proper APA headings to improve readability as you see fit.
When developing your essay, some examples of (but not the only) areas you may want to
consider would be:
· What forces influence and challenge the leader?
· How are ethical dilemma addressed?
· What is the impact of globalization and complexity?
· How do reasoning and ethical foundations guide the leader?
· Where is a Biblical worldview used and evident in ethical leadership?
· What social responsibilities and cultural citizenship issues must be considered?
· Are there cultural pressures that challenge ethical leadership?
· How might ethical leaders promote ethical organizational culture?
· What impact does ethical leadership have on organizational performance?
· How is ethical leadership related to other popular leadership theories?

Christian leaders and followers

Discuss how both as Christian leaders and followers we are called to ethical behavior. How could those Christian leader and follower behaviors influence the building of an ethical organizational culture? How might those behaviors and resulting cultures differ (or not) from those involving non-Christian from an ethical perspective? Incorporate the results of your Ethics Audit to discuss the principles within your organization or if not the member of an organization, use an organization with which you are familiar.

aspect of leadership or organizational ethics

Ethical Leadership Article Critique Assignment Instructions


The Ethical Leadership Article Critique assignment is intended to be an insightful, critical, and thoughtful review of a recent ethical leadership article viewed through the ethical, reasoning, and worldview concepts covered in this and prior coursework. You will examine recent research in ethics with an eye toward developing critical consumer of information practices while being exposed to recent ethical theory work. By more deeply and clearly understanding the ethical leadership theories, arguments, biases, and reasoning fallacies revealed in this critique, you will be better prepared to analyze practices and construct solutions you may face as an ethical leader.


You should select an article on an aspect of leadership or organizational ethics from the Journal of Business Ethics that has been published within the last 5 years as the subject of your critique. An alternative, peer-reviewed article on ethics can be substituted with prior approval by the professor. Requests for exceptions should be submitted via email and include a copy of the article and a short paragraph (3-4 sentences) explaining why you would like to use the article.

The paper is to be a critical examination of the ethical dimensions discussed in the article, the research methods or reasoning used, the biases of the authors (claimed or unspoken), the key important findings, and any resulting questions. You should apply the ethical concepts from BMAL 770, critical reasoning, and worldview perspectives to demonstrate doctoral-level evaluation of published materials

The Ethical Leadership Article Critique paper should be in APA format including cover page, abstract, a 4-6 page body, and references page. In addition to the article reviewed, no less than 2 sources in addition to the course textbooks should be referenced. All referenced material must be properly cited and listed on the references page. 

Remember that every article has strengths, weaknesses, flaws, biases, and shortcomings in addition to their contributions to the field. As a leadership scholar and practitioner, being able to examine published ideas in-depth is critical for understanding and applying ethical leadership principles.